Notice Type
Departmental
Notice Title

Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal

Notice is hereby given, in accordance with section 94(2) of the Motor Vehicle Sales Act 2003, that a Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal has found against the following motor vehicle traders:
MVD 180/06
Decision No.: Wn. 7/07 Sun City Motors Limited (trading as The Car Bazaar) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $2,950.00 and then uplift the vehicle from purchaser’s property.
MVD 82/08
Decision No.: Ak. 65/08 Import Drive Limited Ordered that the trader pay purchaser $14,500.00 plus $562.50 compensation plus $50.00 costs and collect vehicle from purchaser’s address at same time.
MVD 84/08
Decision No.: Ak. 74/08 Supreme Autos Limited Ordered that the finance agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay purchaser $7,000.00 plus the sum of any principal payments.
MVD 86/08
Decision No.: Wn. 28A/08 M S Ford Motors (1998) Limited (trading as M S Ford) and UDC Finance Limited (joined party) Ordered that the credit agreement be declared void. The trader to pay the purchaser the sum of any payments made under the finance agreement and uplift the vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 92/08
Decision No.: Ak. 71/08 GM Vehicle Wholesale Limited (trading as GM Vehicle Wholesale) Ordered that the finance agreement shall vest in the trader. Trader to pay the purchaser the sum of any principal payments.
MVD 129/08
Decision No.: Wn. 34/08 Performance Cars (Dunedin) Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $2,725.53 compensation.
MVD 138/08
Decision No.: Ak. 109/08 Ron McDonald Limited (trading as European Wholesale Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $23,500.00 plus $580.00 compensation plus $50.00 costs. Purchaser is then to return vehicle to trader. The trader to pay $500.00 costs to the Crown.
MVD 144/08
Decision No.: Ak. 116/08 Buy Right Cars Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $14,840.00 plus $346.40 compensation and then collect vehicle from purchaser at its own expense.
MVD 145/08
Decision No.: Ak. 171/08 Larn Holdings Limited (trading as B & C Motor Company) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $11,495.00 plus $616.34 compensation. Purchaser to return vehicle to trader.
MVD 149/08
Decision No.: Ak. 117/08 Jane-Louise Hoult Limited (trading as Contract Vehicle Sales) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser the sum of $2,574.03 compensation.
MVD 152/08
Decision No.: Ak. 118/08 Palm Height Autos Limited Ordered that the contract be declared void and the finance agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay the purchaser the capital content of finance payments less $500.00 and then purchaser to return the vehicle. The purchaser to receive any insurance refunds due.
MVD 209/08
Decision No.: Ak. 160/08 Cars on Broadway Limited Ordered the trader transfer ownership of vehicle into purchaser’s name and return vehicle to purchaser. The purchaser shall arrange for the repair of the vehicle and the trader to reimburse the cost of this repair.
MVD 214/08
Decision No.: Wn. 46/08 Economy Cars Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $7,600.00 and collect the vehicle from the purchaser.
MVD 215/08
Decision No.: Ak. 159/08 Mega Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $16,985.00 and then collect the vehicle from the purchaser at own expense.
MVD 221/08
Decision No.: Ak. 167/08 Cars on Demand Limited Ordered that the contract be void ab initio. The trader is to pay the purchaser $3,675.00 then purchaser to return vehicle to trader.
MVD 226/08
Decision No.: Ak. 180/08 Awapuni Auto Centre Limited (trading as Cartown Tremaine) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $10,500.00 as rejection upheld.
MVD 227/08
Decision No.: Ak. 165/08 Buy Right Cars (Western Springs) Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $12,235.00 plus $250.00 compensation then purchaser to return vehicle to trader.
MVD 230/08
Decision No.: Ak. 174/08 Jasmac Cars Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,120.00 compensation.
MVD 233/08
Decision No.: Ak. 68/09 Texaco NZ Limited (trader) and Ron McDonald Limited (trading as European Wholesale Cars) (joined party) and UDC Finance Limited (joined party) Ordered that the contract be declared void ab initio and the finance agreement shall vest in the trader. Trader to pay the purchaser any capital payments plus $500.00 deposit and $277.70 compensation. Trader to collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 235/08
Decision No.: Ak. 173/08 Auto King Holdings Limited (trading as Auto King) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser the purchase price plus compensation totalling $10,736.25. Purchaser to then ensure trader gets clear title to the vehicle.
MVD 237/08
Decision No.: Ak. 178/08 Urban Enhancement Limited (trading as Urban Wholesale RMVT) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $456.75.
MVD 239/08
Decision No.: Ak. 175/08 Camelot Group Limited (trading as Camelot Cars Ordered that the trader pay $8,950.00 to purchaser then purchaser to return vehicle to trader.
MVD 240/08
Decision No.: Ak. 4/09 Kilkelly Investments Limited (trading as Regent Car Court) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $6,500.00 plus compensation of $411.65 then collect vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 243/08
Decision No.: Ak. 181/08 Michael Grant Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,800.00 and then collect vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 247/08
Decision No.: Ak. 182/08 Premium Cars Limited Ordered that the collateral agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay the purchaser $1,500.00 plus the sum of any principal payments.
MVD 261/08
Decision No.: Ak. 13/09 Texaco NZ Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $899.00, being the extended warranty charge, plus $50.00 costs.
MVD 262/08
Decision No.: Ak. 64/09 Martin David Brown (trading as Martins Wholesale) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $15,750.00 and then uplift vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 266/08
Decision No.: Ak. 7/09 Falcon Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $7,400.00. Purchaser to then return the vehicle to trader.
MVD 269/08
Decision No.: Ak. 8/09 Mark Craft (trading as Kiwi Performance) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $4,980.00 then collect the vehicle from purchaser at own expense.
MVD 271/08
Decision No.: Ak. 16/09 Car Wholesalers Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $300.00 compensation.
MVD 272/08
Decision No.: Ak. 9/09 Trust Motor Group Limited Ordered that the collateral agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay the purchaser the total sum of principal payments plus $7,500.00 and compensation of $163.92. Purchaser to then return vehicle in stated condition.
MVD 6/09
Decision No.: Ak. 23/09 Sandbrook Rolton Limited (trading as The King of Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $2,237.13 compensation plus $774.55 costs.
MVD 8/09
Decision No.: Ak. 19/09 Continental Car Services Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $50,000.00 and then collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 9/09
Decision No.: Ak. 25/09 MMM Holdings Limited (trading as ANZA Motor Company) Ordered that the trader to refund the purchaser $1,245.00 for extended warranty.
MVD 11/09
Decision No.: Ak. 21/09 Robert L Motors Limited Ordered that the credit sale agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay purchaser $300.00 plus any capital payments. The trader is then to collect vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 12/09
Decision No.: Ak. 22/09 BFM Auto Services Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,750.00 compensation.
MVD 17/09
Decision No.: Ak. 30/09 Auto Auctioneers (Hamilton) Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $741.61 compensation.
MVD 18/09
Decision No.: Ak. 26/09 Motor Sales Auckland Limited (trading as Sell It Yourself South Auckland) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $3,999.00 and purchaser to then return vehicle to trader. The trader to pay $500.00 costs to Crown.
MVD 21/09
Decision No.: Ak. 32/09 Kia Motors New Zealand Limited Ordered that the trader to pay the purchaser $4,654.12 compensation.
MVD 22/09
Decision No.: Ak. 31/09 G.J. & S.R. Johnstone Limited (trading as Grant Johnstone Nissan & Suzuki) Ordered that the trader to pay the purchaser $29,990.00. Purchaser to return vehicle to trader at own expense and execute change of ownership.
MVD 30/09
Decision No.: Wn. 6/09 Kerry Harvey Autos Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $17,073.75 and to collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 36/09
Decision No.: Wn. 8/09 Autoworld Richmond Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,000.00 compensation.
MVD 39/09
Decision No.: Ak. 36/09 Firebird Autos Limited (trading as Greenwoods of Highland Park) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $14,195.00. The purchaser to then deliver the vehicle to the trader and sign a transfer of ownership.
MVD 40/09
Decision No.: Ak. 38/09 Sean Francis Hogan (trading as Vehicle Vault) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $3,000.00 refund, $150.00 compensation and $50.00 costs and then collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 45/09
Decision No.: Ak. 41/09 Motive Trading Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $4,450.00 plus $454.38 compensation plus $50.00 costs. Trader to then collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 48/09
Decision No.: Ak. 40/09 City Imported Autos Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $21,990.00 refund plus $1,336.00 compensation.
MVD 55/09
Decision No.: Wn. 11/09 Tamaki Limited (trading as Grange Motor Company) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $44,990.00 plus $204.00 compensation. The purchaser to return the vehicle to the trader.
MVD 56/09
Decision No.: Wn. 14/09 Baja Limited (trading as Cheap Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $7,695.00 refund. Purchaser to return vehicle to trader.
MVD 61/09
Decision No.: Ak. 53/09 Darryl Clifton MacDonald (trading as Darryl’s Autos and trading as Amber and Black Quality Cars 2008) Ordered that the trader to pay the purchaser $5,900.00 refund.
MVD 62/09
Decision No.: Ak. 46/09 Motive Trading Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $4,490.00 plus $426.41 compensation plus $50.00 costs. Trader to collect vehicle at own expense. Trader to pay Crown $450.00 costs.
MVD 72/09
Decision No.: Ak. 54/09 Barry Grouby Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $6,500.00 plus $188.60 costs. Trader to collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 79/09
Decision No.: Wn. 17/09 Manawatu Motors 1970 Limited (trading as Robertson Holden) Ordered that the contract be declared void ab initio. The trader to pay the purchaser $45,000.00. The purchaser to return the vehicle.
MVD 80/09
Decision No.: Ak. 52/09 Leafgreen Enterprises Limited (trading as Cars Unlimited) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,766.30 compensation plus $246.88 costs.
MVD 84/09
Decision No.: Ak. 57/09 G.M. Car Wholesalers Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $6,400.00 and then collect vehicle at its own expense. The trader to pay Crown $450.00 costs.
MVD 85/09
Decision No.: Ak. 55A/09 Harpers For Cars Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser actual costs of repair up to $4,083.76 compensation.
MVD 86/09
Decision No.: Ak. 56/09 Apia Motors Limited Ordered that the collateral credit agreement shall vest in the trader and the trader to pay the purchaser the sum of principal payments. Trader to collect the vehicle.
MVD 87/09
Decision No.: Wn. 19A/09 Swift Car Company Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $3,750.00 compensation.
MVD 88/09
Decision No.: Ak. 61/09 Robert Read (trading as Read’s Trading Company) Ordered that the trader pay up to $786.00 compensation to the purchaser.
MVD 89/09
Decision No.: Ak. 91/09 Lee Tran Hang Ordered that the seller is declared to be a motor vehicle trader. That Lee Tran Hang pay the purchaser $878.09 compensation.
MVD 94/09
Decision No.: Ak. 60/09 Xotica Limited (trading as Xotica Performance Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,807.50 compensation.
MVD 100/09
Decision No.: Ak. 62/09 Planet Cars Limited Ordered that the collateral credit agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay the purchaser any principal payments plus $230.00 consequential damages and uplift the vehicle.
MVD 101/09
Decision No.: Ak. 63/09 Eade Cars Greenlane Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $7,335.86 compensation plus $110.00 costs.
MVD 102/09
Decision No.: Ak. 67/09 SM Motorcycles Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $3,500.00 plus $473.50 compensation. Trader to recover vehicle at own expense.
MVD 106/09
Decision No.: Wn. 22/09 Ram Commercials Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $593.35 compensation.
MVD 108/09
Decision No.: Ak. 66/09 Darryl Clifton MacDonald (trading as Darryl’s Autos and trading as Amber and Black Quality Cars 2008) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $10,950.00 plus $198.40 compensation plus $654.23 costs.
MVD 110/09
Decision No.: Wn. 21/09 Mark Brown Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $877.50 compensation.
MVD 111/09
Decision No.: Ak. 65/09 Nippon Autos Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $3,228.00 and then uplift vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 113/09
Decision No.: Ak. 70/09 Fast 4s and Turbos 2008 Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $12,050.00 refund.
MVD 117/09
Decision No.: Ak. 72/09 Mega Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $11,500.00 plus $50.00 costs and uplift the vehicle at own expense. The trader to pay the Crown $450.00 costs.
MVD 120/09
Decision No.: Ak. 71/09 Keith Lines Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,522.31 compensation.
MVD 121/09
Decision No.: Ak. 73/09 Trademark Autos Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $4,000.00 refund plus $100.00 compensation plus $50.00 costs and uplift the vehicle at its own expense. The trader to pay the Crown $450.00 costs.
MVD 124/09
Decision No.: Ak. 75/09 Joden Finance Limited (trading as Paris Motors) Ordered that trader pay the purchaser $2,850.00 refund plus $725.95 costs. The trader to uplift the vehicle at its own expense.
MVD 128/09
Decision No.: Ak. 80/09 Buy Right Cars Limited Ordered that the collateral credit agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay the purchaser $940.25 plus capital payments. The trader to pay the Crown $450.00 costs.
MVD 129/09
Decision No.: Ak. 88/09 Zara Trading Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,710.00 compensation plus $350.00 costs.
MVD 130/09
Decision No.: Ak. 99/09 Lantis Holdings Limited (trading as 4 Guys Autobarn/Autozone) Ordered that the trader remedy faults with the vehicle at their expense then supply the purchaser with copies of the repair invoices.
MVD 131/09
Decision No.: Ak. 86/09 Admirals Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser up to $1,058.06 compensation, upon production of a receipt from the repairer.
MVD 134/09
Decision No.: Ak. 87/09 Richard Anthony Williams (trading as The Car Place) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $910.00 compensation plus $1,146.30 to the purchaser’s repairer.
MVD 145/09
Decision No.: Ak. 92/09 Glenfield Wholesale Limited (trading as Real Wholesale Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchasers $9,950.00. The purchasers are to return the vehicle to the trader.
MVD 148/09
Decision No.: Ak. 93/09 Marcus Mate Dean (trading as Dean Automotive) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $7,955.00 and collect the vehicle at its own expense including storage and towing costs.
MVD 149/09
Decision Nos.: Wn. 27/09 and Wn. 27A/09 Supervalue Cars Limited Ordered that trader pay the purchaser $5,000.00 refund plus $239.53 compensation plus $387.30 costs. Trader to collect vehicle at own expense.
MVD 151/09, MVD 152/09, MVD 154/09
Decision No.: Ak. 100/09 Van Man 2009 Limited (trading as Wholesale Vans Direct) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $4,300.00 refund plus $3,341.26 compensation plus $150.00 costs. Ordered that the trader is to pay $450.00 costs to the Crown.
MVD 153/09
Decision No.: Wn. 28/09 Capital Wholesale Limited (trading as Coventry Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $5,695.04 compensation.
MVD 156/09
Decision No.: Ak. 98/09 Mega Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $700.00 compensation plus $50.00 costs.
MVD 158/09
Decision No.: Ak. 94/09 All Cars 5000 Limited Ordered that the finance agreement shall vest in the trader. The trader to pay the purchaser all principal payments plus $6,750.00 refund plus $157.79 compensation. Purchaser to return the vehicle to the trader.
MVD 160/09
Decision No.: Ak. 107/09 Tamaki Limited (trading as Grange Motor Company) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $3,788.74 compensation plus $50.00 costs.
MVD 163/09
Decision No.: Ak. 102/09 Glenfield Wholesale Limited (trading as Real Wholesale Cars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $167.21 compensation. The trader to pay the Crown $450.00 costs.
MVD 165/09
Decision No.: Wn. 31/09 Autoworld Richmond Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $1,590.67 compensation.
MVD 169/09
Decision No.: Ak. 105/09 Tarnica Cars Limited Ordered that the trader complete repairs to the vehicle then obtain a VTNZ warrant of fitness and return the vehicle to purchaser.
MVD 170/09
Decision No.: Ak. 106/09 Cheapcars NZ Limited (trading as Repocars) Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $4,153.81 refund. Purchaser to then return vehicle to trader. The trader to pay the Crown $350.00 costs.
MVD 180/09
Decision No.: Ak. 111/09 Storer Motors Limited Ordered that the trader pay the purchaser $6,000.00 refund.
A copy of any of the Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal’s decisions may be obtained from the office of the Motor Vehicle Disputes Tribunal at Tribunals Unit, Auckland District Court, Private Bag 92020, Auckland 1142.
Dated at Auckland this 9th day of March 2010.
KAINE THOMPSON, for Chief Executive, Ministry of Justice.